Why Your Perfect Candidate Might Not Look Perfect (Yet)

Back To News & Insights

What's a 'Perfect Candidate?'

In today's challenging job market, finding the right talent isn't about holding out for a mythical perfect candidate. It's about being smart, flexible, and open-minded. With skills shortages and a competitive hiring landscape, employers who stick rigidly to traditional recruitment approaches risk missing out on exceptional talent.

We speak to countless brilliant professionals who would never have passed the traditional "tick-box" recruitment approach. Why? Because talent isn't about a perfect match - it's about potential, passion and the ability to grow.

The Recruitment Paradox

Today's job market presents some interesting contradictions. Employers are becoming increasingly specific about their requirements, creating job specifications so narrow they effectively build walls around potential talent. Simultaneously, they're facing:


• Longer time-to-hire periods
• Increased recruitment costs
• Shrinking talent pools
• Higher candidate expectations

Understanding the value of talent beyond the checklist

When we look at successful team members, we rarely find individuals who matched 100% of a job specification on day one. What we see is:
• Adaptability
• Genuine passion
• Learning agility
• Cultural alignment
• Innovative thinking

Don't fall into the 'hidden potential' trap

Most employers unknowingly fall into this trap, by ignoring candidates who don't tick every box. Instead, they:
• Fixate on exact experience levels
• Demand precise technical skills
• Overlook transferable capabilities
• Undervalue potential for growth

But, by thinking more broadly they might find:
• A candidate from a different industry might bring revolutionary cross-sector insights
• Someone with 80% of technical skills but exceptional problem-solving abilities could outperform a seemingly perfect match
• Professionals willing to learn can often adapt faster than those who believe they know everything

Where we add value

In a recruitment landscape dominated by rigid, checkbox approaches, we stand out by taking a holistic, forward-thinking view of talent acquisition. While traditional recruitment fixates on exact experience, precise technical skills, and narrow industry boundaries, we prioritise the human potential behind the CV. Our approach focuses on understanding core competencies, learning potential, individual motivations, transferable skills, and cultural compatibility. By looking beyond surface-level requirements, we help organisations unlock exceptional talent that drives real business impact.

Practical Strategies for Employers

Think carefully about your Job Specifications

  1. Distinguish Between Essential and Desirable Skills
    • Think carefully about non-negotiable requirements
    • Identify skills that can be developed
  2. Create Robust Development Pathways
    • Design comprehensive onboarding programmes to get new hires up to speed
    • Invest in continuous learning to maximise potential and retain strong talent
    • Support professional growth through regular reviews
  3. Embrace Diverse Talent Backgrounds
    • Look beyond traditional recruitment channels - there's life beyond LinkedIn!
    • Consider candidates from adjacent industries
    • Value different professional experiences

The most successful organisations are those that view recruitment as an investment in potential, not a transactional process of filling seats.

Get in touch with us today to find out how we can help you to find that elusive 'perfect' hire!